am i atheist or agnostic

By | Uncategorized

Dec 02

I think another possibility is that we simply cannot detect the greater pattern…. According to Wikipedia’s definition of agnostic atheism, “Agnostic atheism, also called atheistic agnosticism, is a philosophical position that encompasses both atheism and agnosticism. He edited the Secular Review from 1882; it was renamed Agnostic Journal and Eclectic Review and closed in 1907. Please post respectful comments even when you have strong opinions. By this definition I would actually be an agnostic atheist. But at this point, however, the lecturer added as an aside, saying (quote): But, they can express different reasons for their certainty. Well said. Question. There is no middle ground where you call yourself an agnostic. (It seems to me that you’ve rightly ruled out not only the Christian god, but any god that could be both omnipotent and well-disposed toward us.) Support the creation of more videos like this at Patreon! An atheist, like a Christian, holds that we can know whether or not there is a God. Therefore, to a large extent the answer to the question depends on the beliefs or worldview of the questioner. So I’m honest. “Not atheistic” means that you‘re not in the class of people who don’t believe in any god - so you’re a theist, you believe in at least one god. I gather that, given your admirably conceived and expressed response to the problem of evil (here and especially in God’s Problem), any existent “spiritual power/intelligence” would have to be either A) malevolent toward us and all sentient beings in this world, B) unable to control events and conditions in this world (e.g., perhaps like a cosmic bungler, unable to fix what it botched when it set the world going) or C) entirely unconcerned about this world (like Epicurus’ gods). what does “God” mean? But no, the modern term was not invented in relation to ancient Gnosticism. Dr Ehrman, Science deals in likelihoods, probabilities. Agnostic vs Atheist a Spectrum. It is not gravely sinful because it does anybody harm, and that is … But I do believe in a scientific form of creator. I can imagine Colbert interviews can be quite daunting. But surely there is no indication that the term “agnostic” is in any way associated with or derived from the first century beliefs of the “Gnostics”, is there?). The first is the more common sense of the term, of course, in which “agnostic” is used to describes the state of simply not knowing one way or the other (If I understand correctly, this is how the word is being used above). Do We Have Paul’s Original Letter to the Philippians? Or have you ever questioned your faith and/or belief in God? (This is a lifted comment from Huff Post; something to think about) There’s no empirical objective construct tagged by the three letter combination “g-o-d”. Agnostic? (Well, I did *kind* of enjoy them; but it’s a challenge, knowing that no matter what you say, you’re going to get *zinged*.) I think the world would be a much better place without religion. By this they mean to identify themselves as doubters on the question of a gods existence. Thanks again for sharing and being a well-reasoned voice in these debates. Some have argued that because so many people report having had “religious experiences”, photisms, voices, etc., that constitutes proof that there is a divine being. Its interest to me is merely an intellectual question only. So is unicorn, and, well, a lot of other things that may or may not ever have existed…. Prof. Ehrman wrote, “Why they are so incensed that I don’t follow suit, however, continues to be a mystery to me.”, Apparently you said “Sibboleth” instead of “Shibboleth.”. No atheist I know will have 100% certainty that there is no God, just like you can’t reasonably be 100% certain about anything. I wasn’t raised religious and I don’t believe in god. While there are possibilities, I try to make decisions about life based on measurable, reliable, and testable evidence. To people (particularly believers) who haven’t thought deeply about its meaning, calling yourself an atheist implies a sense of certainty that I think is unwarranted in the case of most atheists. Did you enjoy your interviews with Colbert? Dr Ehrman wrote “(I sometimes believe in Dionysus/Bacchus, but that’s another story…)” I would like to hear that story. The answer is no, I really don’t. I personally do not care one way or another. How does organized religion make you feel? As always, Dr. Ehrman, well stated! An agnostic atheist doesn't believe in any gods while an agnostic theist believes in the existence of at least one god. Are You More Atheist Or Agnostic? While I am open to the notion that god could very well exsist it's more on a scale of 5% chance god exsists 95% chance he dosent. If you don’t belong yet, JOIN!! No — it’s intimidating! Agnostic-atheists cannot simplify their self-designation as “atheist” for the chic value because it is inaccurate to do so. , Based on your last paragraph, I would draw a conclusion that you are agnostic – you don’t know but are open to a divine-like something because you don’t know for sure (agnosis – no direct knowledge; gnosis – direct knowledge). * All quotes are from the WordWeb Dictionary. ), I guess if we wanted to summarize these two views the distinction would be something like: I have a somewhat tangential question concerning the word agnostic. The Christian holds that we can know there is a God; the atheist, that we can know there is not. Everyday experience has repeatedly demonstrated to me that ATHEISTS are militant; AGNOSTICS, not so much. I thought you did a good job on both of your appearances. This site is a haven for those who are pushing back against the norm, and a place for believers of gods to have their beliefs exposed as false should they want to try their hand at confronting us. It has puzzled me before what you meant by being an agnostic…especially after I heard you say that you don’t believe in God. For a few years now I've considered myself an atheist as I don't believe in any deities or religions. Â© . I get on with my life on earth and am indifferent to the Universe I see the work of the Creator and his presence in everything “…a group from the first and second century C.E. . I'm not aware of terms that label the different reason. This is one of the clearest dissections of the two terms I’ve come across. Bertrand Russell Christians label me as a HERETIC (hence, my chosen and frequently used e-mail and Twitter name of “Heterodoxus”). Is Mary Magdalene the Founder of Christianity? In Why I am an Agnostic (c. 1889) he claims that agnosticism is "the very reverse of atheism". If this is your perspective, why not refer to yourself as an atheist? The first thing to say is that I had no idea how militant both atheists and agnostics could be about their labels, until I became an agnostic myself! Why Finding an “Original” Text is So Unexpectedly Complicated. At the end of the day, when I’m perfectly honest with myself, I conclude that when asked if I’m an atheist, I can’t adequately respond until I have a better understanding of what the questioner is asking, i.e. sterlingdean Level 6 Mar 16, 2020 . I see no evidence of a personal and loving God and that has made me an agnostic. Am I atheist or agnostic? “Agnostic” is a qualifier to the theist/atheist label. Your final result may surprise you. By continuing, you agree to Quizony's Privacy Policy and Cookie use. called the “Gnostics”. I will say that your interview on the Colbert Report was quite enjoyable. Personally, I prefer agnostic for pretty much the same reason you give, but I won’t protest if someone calls me an atheist accept possibly to point out that I’m not a strong/hard one. Comments posted must be limited to 200 words or less. My dictionary informs me that an ATHEIST is “Someone who denies the existence of god,”* while an AGNOSTIC is “A person who claims that they cannot have true knowledge about the existence of God (but does not deny that God might exist)”. Where do you stand on the spectrum. Am I Agnostic or Atheist? Most atheists are agnostics and most agnostics are atheists. I called such experiences “brain chemistry.” I have argued that no one has seen wind, and in previous millenia, people’s imaginations created Aeolus and Zephyrus to account for the phenomenon. Do you have any comment about these possibilities? – “I *don’t* know if there’s a god” There were some specific labels about whether or not you'd believe we couldn't know about it (strong agnostic, or even some ignostics I suppose). Believer? So if anyone can present compelling evidence for the existence of any kind of deity I’m ready to listen. I am a recent deconvert from Christianity. All Rights Reserved. I am an atheist and a secular humanist and do my best to follow the Ten Commitments. Credit and Debit Cards Processed: Visa, MasterCard, Maestro, AmericanExpress, Diners Club, JCB, UnionPay, ApplePay, and GooglePay. Describing them in terms of faith vs. knowledge makes a lot of sense. Very honest and something I have always wondered about you in the back of my mind when reading your works. I think there’s something worth noting, and probably obvious, in your statement about agnosticism: “But as to whether there is some greater spiritual power/intelligence in the universe, I’m agnostic.”. Schedule recurring donations to Bart's foundation using the form below. “Isn’t an agnostic an atheist without balls?” and I liked your response at the end. Click Here for all Posts in a List Format. I’ll be trying to wrap my mind around that. vs Do not think about the answers too long. Each blog member is allowed to make 2 comments a day. Which, I suppose, was my point. For a time I was substituting “non-theist” for “atheist” account the baggage that the latter term carries. If you don’t think God exists, why do you refer to yourself as an agnostic? There is a big difference between these two things. Hi, I am an 18 year old male and have considered myself an Atheist for a number of years now. If the question is do I believe in the literal existence of Yahweh and/or his eternal son Jesus, then I am certainly an atheist. Hey I have a quick question. Video produced by Confronting Ignorance. “Moreover, the term does seem to me to convey a greater sense of humility in the face of an incredibly awesome universe, about which I know so little.” But I think “God” *is* a word. Recently, I was listening to a lecture on the opening chapters of Genesis. Agnostic atheism is a philosophical position that encompasses both atheism and agnosticism.Agnostic atheists are atheistic because they do not hold a belief in the existence of any deity, and are agnostic because they claim that the existence of a deity is either unknowable in principle or currently unknown in fact.. I think people who get worked up about labels need to realize there are more important issues in the world. I've always labeled myself an agnostic, but it's not clearly defined.. Could you tell me what I am, based on my beliefs? The atheist does not believe there is a God; the agnostic believes that we do not or cannot know if God exists. My question has more to do with your (non) belief in Jesus rather than in a sort of grand cosmic intelligence such as the Judeo-Christian God. – “I *can’t* know if there’s a god.”. Thanks for the answer. Yet, it is as you say. Am I atheist or agnostic? I never worship, pray, engage in any sort of religious organization, and think most if not all organized religion is nonsense. I see it as also a question of knowledge. Are You An Atheist, An Agnostic, Or A Believer? If you think you answered incorrectly, you can always go back to any question and change your answer. What Does It Even Mean to Have an “Original” of An Ancient Writing? The Rational Response Squad is a group of atheist activists who impact society by changing the way we view god belief. Think you know where you stand on the religious spectrum? Agnosticism deals with knowledge. So, if you don't believe in God, but don't claim certainty, you are an agnostic atheist. I tend to avoid both labels in venues where the atheist vs agnostic debate is prone to breakout, calling myself a non-believer or skeptic. A "gnostic" atheist (which you are not) is someone who is certain that there are no gods. Could Paul’s Letter to the Philippians be TWO Letters? “Gnostics” were called that because they claimed to “know” (the truth — e.g., about the divine realm, the world, who humans really were, etc.). But speaking popularly, I think that all of us would say in regard to those gods that we were Atheists. Belief in god/s is something that is a very heated thing these days? An intresting artical I found see below A good deal of people consider themselves to be agnostics. Am I an atheist or an agnostic? It is intended for fun only so do not treat the result too seriously :). Just sayin’. My own personal position is that, while I do not like the term “atheist” as a label (we don’t use the label non-alchemist or non-astrologist), I place myself very close to the “no-god” end of the spectrum because of how I view the burden of proving an idea. Nothing planned just now, but, well, I don’t control such things! You can share it with your friends :). Since I became a Rationalist I have found that there is still considerable scope in the world for the practical importance of a rationalist outlook, not only in matters of geology, but in all sorts of practical matters, such as divorce and birth control, and a question which has come up quite recently, artificial insemination, where bishops tell us that something is gravely sinful, but it is only gravely sinful because there is some text in the Bible about it. Huxley originally coined the term ‘agnostic’ to respond to claims of knowledge by believers of things they couldn’t possibly know, in essence a response to unreasonable certainty. Atheists are against all religion; agnostics are accepting of religion. Maybe the creator is something in all living things cells, maybe it's a ball of energy out in space that creates matter, maybe the creator exist in a different dimension. It would be great to see an interview on your recent book…but hopefully your next book (which I am excited for) will score you an intimidating interview. An “Agnostic” is someone who does *not* know (e.g., about whether there is a God). But until recently I have started to question whether or not I would be considered an Atheist or Agnostic. Like most of these questions about the terms "agnostic" and "atheist", this one is based on two misconceptions about the technical meanings of these terms. To find out take this quiz now! Great explanation. However even though I personally don't believe in a God I don't aggressively deny the existence of one as others atheist seem to do. The agnostic atheist may be contrasted with the agnostic theist, who does believe that one or more deities exist but claims that the existence or nonexistence of such is unknown or cannot be known.” Although you just say you’re an agnostic, I believe you more fit the pattern of the agnostic theist. But if God can be defined more broadly, either as any kind of universal intelligence or even a nebulous “force” (in which case I’m still waiting on my lightsaber), then I have to honestly cop to agnostic. An atheist lacks faith in God, believes there is no god, or lacks awareness of gods.An agnostic either believes that it is impossible to know whether there is a god or is noncommittal on the issue.The difference may seem small, but atheism and agnosticism are actually vastly different worldviews. Agnostic Atheist Vs. Agnostic Theist . Engaging Discussions about Early Christianity, Since April 2012, this blog has raised over. The effects are real, hence the myth part, but the explanation was dead wrong. On the evidence I see I do not think a god exists. That seems kind narrow to me. Good post, thanks for sharing. Most agnostic atheists are VERY close to be certain. I have been getting this question a lot, and so I’ve decided to try to explain my position a bit more fully here in this post. Do you want to build a bridge to your Christian friends and colleagues? Take this quiz to see the truth for yourself. At the end of the quiz we will give you the result. I was spoke with Lawrence Krauss and he will be on Colbert shortly but he seemed a tad nervous about his upcoming interview for his book. (That is, I certainly understand the etymological connection between the name “Gnostic” and the term “agnostic”. I don't believe in any religion. I was raised as a Catholic but began to question and ultimately reject the concept of a God. Dr. Ehrman I think that that was beautifully and concisely put. They demonstrate to us what we can become and what we can accomplish if we simply choose to. Wow! Describing various interpretations that these chapters had been given over history. I believe in people like Gandhi, Martin Luther King, and Nelson Mandela, so why not Jesus of Nazareth? Questions. Are You An Atheist, An Agnostic, Or A Believer? The atheist does not believe there is a God, the agnostic isn't sure if he believes in God. I’ve wrestled with what to call myself for the past few years since my Pentecostal faith (followed by a more fuzzy general Christian faith) have unraveled. 149,412 visitors' top results Created June 2011. Of course know one absolutely knows for sure 100% if god exists but that’s only because no one absolutely knows anything 100%. Could it be that you don’t believe the Christian God exists, but are open to the possibility that some kind of higher power exists (this is my perspective) and this is why you call yourself agnostic? by Matthew Perpetua. Any chance that you will be appearing again? When we look into the respective beliefs of both atheists and agnostics, more often than not, they are the same. It would have to be over wine. I do find it funny that internet community of non-religious often get caught up on these labels. How does organized religion make you feel? I haven't really been into those subjects in awhile. I'm the biggest non believer in a god in the whole wide world but consider myself an agnostic. Aeolus and Zephyrus have been banished to the archives of legend and/or myth. No, I don’t believe in Jesus; I think he was completely human, and was later transformed into something more…. Take this quiz to see where you stand with your faith. Obviously, no one can make an absolute statement about God’s existence or nonexistence but to say that atheism is based on faith and agnosticism knowledge makes it sound like atheism is not based on any kind of evidence or lack thereof, and therefore it has nothing to do with epistemology. parts: 29 modi . I’ll remember that. Atheist since you don't believe in one; agnostic since you don't know. People are either a theist or an atheist. Ross championed agnosticism in opposition to the atheism of Charles Bradlaugh as an open-ended spiritual exploration. And at first I was strictly agnostic, but I began to see how in some ways an agnostic is an athiest. They usually hold to this position of doubt because reason compels them to … Do you think that you have to go to church in order to be a good person? I think this is one of those arguments that is so passionate because so little rides on the outcome! All well and good. Post; Browse. I require evidence to allow a level of certainty analogous to the burden of proof in criminal cases in the United States-beyond a reasonable doubt. Atheist? Ok to be honest I'm just writing random stuff here because I'm required to by GoToQuiz. Now we see that wind is molecules of nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide, and atoms of argon in motion, exerting pressure on whatever surface they encounter. Please keep your comments relevant to the issues discussed in the post. I suppose if you applied the same hyper-literal approach to “agnostic” it would simply mean “not a gnostic”, which would describe pretty much everyone today! I like your definitions based on “faith” and “knowledge.” I, too, have been having trouble putting my thoughts on this in a box. Atheism and agnosticism can coexist because they are both dealing with different modalities of thought and belief. The Agnostic suspends judgment, saying that there are not sufficient grounds either for affirmation or for denial. There is no real difference. Women   |  Men   |  Couples   |  Adults   |  Kids   |  Living   |  Health   |  Career   |  Animals   |  Entertainment   |  Food   |  Personality   |  Technology   |  Sport   |  Travel, Home  |  Advertise  |  Contact  |  About  |  Privacy Policy  |  Cookie Policy. FOR THE REST OF THIS POST, log in as a member. However, not sure about making atheism equivalent to faith. I find the overwhelming lack of evidence for god compelling. I do, even if (or maybe because) he was “completely human”. Take this quiz to see where you stand with your faith. Are You Atheist, Agnostic, Pantheist, Deist, Pagan or what? But I do not disagree with anything you have stated in your answer, as I too am more interested in knowledge. Concisely put, how do you make sense of the epistemological case (the “faith [that] might not rest in the wisdom of men but in the power of God”, and “secret wisdom”) advocated by Paul in 1 Corinthians 1&2? Are you an atheist, agnostic or believer? However, both do not make the claim to have the knowledge to back up this belief. All comments will be moderated by the post author before release. START. Recently, world famous atheist Richard Dawkins recently called himself an agnostic and confused a lot of people who had never read his position on this in The God Delusion. Very well said Bart. Hmm ok, Yeah I mean I see Goz using agnostic atheist as a term to suggest that she is open to reasonable debate, but I see in her posts that she shuts down believers and makes comments that clearly disparage belief and religion, that is not the commenting of an agnostic, that is an atheist who thinks religion is stupid. But like you I am an ex-christian so I at least can change my mind on the issue. You can’t reasonably be 100% certain that there is no Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer! 3 Comments. Thanks for referring me here. Here is a spectrum of agnostic vs atheist: Gnostic Atheist: do not believe in a god and also believe that they know there are no gods. Fundamentally, there is still some question and that is why they're agnostic. Atheists are in some degree agnostics for the reason you described here. We just can’t go around assigning letter combinations as tags to every figment of everyone’s imagination without destroying our language. I think the problem is that we have no access to “the wisdom of God” except through our own brains — there’s no other way! If you would like to ask a question, simply ask it in your comment. The term atheist opens up the can of worms between “soft atheists” (who simply lack a belief in God) and “hard atheists” (who actively assert God doesn’t exist), and is freighted with so much societal baggage that I’ve been loath to claim it. I am confused about whether i should be athiest or agnostic Like even though religious fanatics are quite delusional about thing's that they have no proof to prove but we atheists also don't have any kinda prove to give about whether death leads to something else or not either. I remember you being on the Colbert Report, and the host asked you, “Isn’t an agnostic just an atheist without balls?” Hilarious line! This test is not based on any scientific study whatsoever. Do you think that you have to go to church in order to be a good person? More specifically that the answers to such questions are, virtually by definition, beyond the scope of human knowledge.. (This is typified in many brands of philosophy –for example Christian Existentialism, most notably in the works of Kierkegaard– where the acceptance of god is considered possible only as an explicit act of faith, and never of knowledge. Interesting. That is a faith-based term once again, so that doesn’t make a different statement than “atheist.” I think you may have cut the fog. If so, you choose “atheist.”, I’m glad *you* thought it was hilarious ! I see it as a distinction that is perfectly arbitrary. Am I correct in this inference, or am I am overlooking another possibility? Yes. But the standard for me is very high. Well, roughly speaking it’s right. A Fund-Raising Webinar: What Can We Really Know about the Birth of Jesus?? So my default position is that no god exists until someone can demonstrate such compelling evidence. I believe that no one can prove god exists but at the same time they can't prove he dosent. But there is the more technical (and I believe both more original and more interesting) meaning of the term that ties deeply into its epistemological roots. BuzzFeed Staff. In this context the lecturer –in all other respects first-rate– mentioned: what so ever. I know it doesn’t matter but when people ask I want to make sure my definition is correct. (At the same time, I chastise myself mildly for letting other people’s interpretations of a term affect my stance toward it rather than its actual meaning.). Why don’t you believe in Jesus? Take this quiz to see the truth for yourself. So you are not alone in feeling the intimidation of being zinged. Atheism deals with faith. “This is where we get the term ‘agnostic’.”, This can’t possibly be correct can it? or am I nogostic atheist. _________________________ Or how about the thought of attending church on Sundays? Please ask only one question per comment posted. I too have seen the war waged between agnostics and atheists, with atheists happy with nothing other than forcing self-professed agnostics to a complete denial of any gods in any way whatsoever. If a person is asked if they believe in God answers, “I’m agnostic”, that person is answering a different question. “God” isn’t a word so it can’t be framed into a question of belief, disbelief or doubt. It is not absolute certainty because that is nearly impossible. Join C.I. BUT in an infinite universe I cannot rule out the possibility (however small) that their may be one. I prefer to identify myself as a SKEPTIC; i.e., “Someone who habitually doubts accepted beliefs” (spec., orthodox Judeo-Christian beliefs). The agnostic atheist may be contrasted with the agnostic theist, who does believe that one or more deities exist but claims that the existence or nonexistence of such is unknown or cannot be known.” Although you just say you’re an agnostic, I believe you more fit the pattern of the agnostic theist.

Antique American Hooked Rugs, Aperture Magazine Earth, Kill Wisteria With Vinegar, Traumatic Brain Injury And Home Care, Human-centered Design Definition, Yugioh Legendary Collection 2 Mega Pack, Bose Qc35 Gaming Mic, Avocado Rice Bowl, Coltmans Co Uk,

About the Author